Vs. Magazine's Fall 2012 Covers Feature Rachel McAdams and Liv Tyler

Photos courtesy of Vs. Magazine

Amanda Seyfried (left) and Rachel McAdams (right)

Eeny, meeny, miny, moe, which magazine muse to spend your dough? Good luck deciding which of Vs. Magazine's four covers you'll be buying this month.

After the magazine's six-cover Spring 2012 spread, the fashion publication may have put a cap on the covers, but certainly didn't sacrifice any sex appeal or star power for Fall 2012.

With smoldering heavily-lined eyes, a dark pout and slicked back strands, Amanda Seyfried's cover was photographed by Guy Aroch, showing an edgier side of the actress then we've seen in her routine rom-com roles.

Rachel McAdams goes more au naturale with wind-swept blonde locks and a barely-there makeup look in a stunning cover shot taken by budding photog Drew Barrymore, who shot Shailene Woodley in the magazine's Spring issue.

Photos courtesy of Vs. Magazine

Liv Tyler (left) and Coco Rocha (right0

Submerged in the water, Liv Tyler rocks wet hair, a sultry gaze and nude lips in a stunning shot taken by Helena Christensen, one of Vs.'s Spring cover girls.

Ellen von Unwerth captures Coco Rocha flaunting her model behavior; elegant, slight beehive updo, glam cat-eyes and dark lips.

Plus, click through our gallery of all the 2012 September covers.

Which is your favorite cover shot? Let us know in the comments section below.